December 14, 2022 3 min read

Both vinyl flooring and hardwood flooring can be amazing choices for a variety of homes—which can make it tricky to pick between the two. This is especially true if you factor in waterproof flooring brands like Mannington, whose luxury vinyl plank models are the spitting image of real hardwood.

Luckily, you’ve got help in making your decision right here. Below, E Hardwoods & Flooring, where you can buy hardwood flooring online, discusses in which environments each respective flooring type shines, as well as which one might be best for you.

Hardwood Flooring: When You’re Looking for a Heirloom

Hardwood flooring is one of the most, if not the most, long-lasting flooring types out there. In fact, there have been cases of the stuff lasting for a century, according to The Spruce! While it’s certainly not common, with proper flooring care and the right flooring model and species, it’s not outside the realm of possibility.

Hardwood flooring is great for broad swaths of space that you intend to keep in the family. It’s an investment flooring, but one that’s well worth the upfront payment—and the expense that comes with its care in the years following.

A Couple More Pros And Cons of Hardwood Flooring

You have a lot to think about when deciding between hardwood flooring and vinyl flooring. You'll need to consider the room the flooring will be in and determine how much wear and tear will occur. You'll also need to think about where you live and the overall temperature and humidity levels.

So, if you are considering hardwood, keep these pros and cons in mind:

  • Pro - Hardwood comes in many finishes: There is a wide range of high quality hardwood flooring brands. One many people recommend is Paramount. This brand is an excellent example of how even flooring made with specific kinds of wood, such as oak, can come in many colors and finishes.

  • Con - Hardwood is pretty pricey: Even if you love the look of hardwood flooring, it is more expensive than many other flooring types. If hardwood is out of your budget, it's likely worth going with a similar but cheaper option.
  • Con - Hardwood isn't always the best for high humidity:If you live in an area with a lot of moisture or need flooring for a bathroom or kitchen, hardwood is hard to maintain.

Overall, hardwood lasts for decades and looks excellent, but you'll have to weigh the benefits and drawbacks.

Vinyl Flooring: When Water Tightness and Low Maintenance are Priorities

Vinyl flooring excels in spaces like kitchens, bathrooms, and mudrooms—anywhere it can put its watertight nature to work. Spills and slop are no match for this stuff; wipe it up with a damp cloth and some soap if necessary when you see it, and go on with your day!

It’s also incredibly low-maintenance flooring. You won’t need to refinish or sand it down; just vacuum and mop it now and again to keep it looking its best.

More Pros and Cons Of Vinyl Flooring

If vinyl flooring seems like it might be a better option for you, here are a few more pros and cons of this flooring type to consider.

  • Con - Vinyl flooring isn’t as long-lasting as hardwood:While vinyl can still last for years, it’s just not going to withstand for decades like hardwood flooring can. If you want something you won't have to ever replace, hardwood might be a better bet.
  • Pro - Vinyl flooring comes in many design styles: Along with different finishes, vinyl comes in many plank and tile styles, so you can choose the aesthetic that matches your home.

  • Pro - Vinyl is cheaper: If you think hardwood might be out of your budget, vinyl flooring is a much cheaper option that still looks great.

So, generally speaking, luxury vinyl flooring is best for more humid rooms and if you’re looking to save some money.

So What’s the Right One for me?

Simple: ask yourself what you’re looking for out of your flooring. If it’s a treasured heirloom that you’ll keep in your family for generations, go with the solid hardwood. Waterproof flooring is perfect for you if you’re looking for a functional solution that can stand up to any number of spills.

At the end of the day, each flooring type has its respective strengths. No one type is better than the other—they’re each the proper fit for certain homes.

E Hardwoods & Flooring: All Your Favorite Brands, All Amazing Prices

We’re proud to stock high-quality brands of both vinyl and hardwood; you’re sure to find just what you’re looking for. Shop our massive online stock today and contact us if you ever have any flooring-related questions!